In 141 of 142 eviction cases observed by community members, Springfield tenants had no attorney. Landlords were represented in 123. Most hearings lasted under ten minutes. In a courtroom where the stakes are a family’s home, one had a lawyer and the other did not. The solution: a Right to Counsel (RTC) ordinance. But it’s been stuck in the City Council’s Community Involvement Committee for nearly two years.
STUN released Locked Out, a report on Springfield, Missouri’s eviction crisis this past November 17th. It is built on five years of Springfield eviction data put together by Princeton University’s Eviction Lab research team, a one-year analysis of CaseNet eviction data for Springfield, and four months of people-powered court watch where community members were trained to observe eviction court proceedings. Community volunteers saw tenants asking for more time, trying to negotiate with landlords’ legal teams in the hallway, and losing on procedural errors.
This is not a Springfield problem alone, A 2012 study found St. Louis tenants won .04% of the cases that went to trial, and 46% ended with a sheriff’s execution of eviction. The imbalance seen in Springfield is old, and the lack of counsel is a statewide issue.
In 2025, landlords filed 2,292 eviction cases against Springfield’s 42,595 renter households, a 38% increase in just five years. More than half of the verified cases involved tenants who were only one month behind on rent at the time of filing. For the majority of households at risk of eviction, the right support at the right time is the critical difference between a temporary crisis they can move forward from and the start of a devastating cycle of loss: losing their homes, personal belongings, educational opportunities, and jobs, which can even lead to family separation.
RTC is about ensuring fairness in our courtrooms. Ensuring that cases are decided on the merits by a judge who can hear both sides of the story, not based on who has more money. That is the gap a lawyer closes. Councilmember Brandon Jenson, the ordinance’s sponsor, said after observing court watch: “I saw compassion from the judge who sometimes noted that he regretted the outcome that he was required to provide under the law. That just really struck me a couple of times. That folks may not know how to navigate the system, and so you have to follow the law as the judge and your hands can be tied.”
The evidence that RTC works is not theoretical, and much of it is close to home. Kansas City’s program cut default judgments from 45.9% to 37.5% and eviction judgments from 60.7% to 50.9% in its first three years. St. Louis, which enacted its own ordinance in 2023, just secured a major funding boost: from $360,000 to $1 million in 2027. But St. Louis also offers a warning: in its first years, the program served 1,352 defendants, but only 343 received full legal defense, the rest got limited help or a referral. Tenants packed a Council hearing demanding a permanent, fully funded line item. The lesson for Springfield is not just that RTC works, it’s that passing an ordinance without fully funding it leaves most tenants on their own.
Nearly two years ago, a Right to Counsel proposal was introduced at City Council and referred to the Community Involvement Committee. It has appeared on the agenda twice, for no more than 30 minutes each time. The committee has yet to take up the research the referral asked for. The majority of meetings have been canceled. Springfield’s city council committees typically return bills in six to eight months with a recommendation; this one has been there for nearly two years. Constituents showed up at the Nov 17 press conference and packed the committee meeting that followed. They have sent hundreds of messages to Council asking for a transparent process and a public decision on the matter.
The fiscal case doesn’t rest on projections alone: Cleveland’s independent evaluation found $2.47 returned for every $1 invested, while Nashville’s found $4.18. In Springfield, the report recommends a phased plan that starts smaller than the eventual goal: $800,000 in Year 1, serving 252 tenants, of which $97,000 is reserved for rental assistance for households with minor children. At full implementation in Year 5, the program would serve 1,260 tenants at roughly $3.01 million annually, far less than the cost of doing nothing. The most recent Springfield-specific estimate puts the annual public cost of one unsheltered adult at roughly $30,597. At the January 2025 Point-in-Time count of 588 people, that’s about $17.6 million annually in downstream costs. These are planning estimates, not audited figures, but they point in the same direction: prevention is cheaper than the alternative.
But the fiscal case is not the whole case, the moral case is far simpler: tenants behind the numbers are trying to keep a roof over their families’ heads, stay near their jobs and their kids’ schools, and hold on to the stability they’ve built.
As an affordable housing policy manager at Empower Missouri, I’ve worked alongside local community partners and national experts for more than two years to understand the issue, learn best practices, data gather and coalition build. The report is out, the evidence is in, and the ordinance needs to move out of the Community Involvement Committee for a full public vote of the council.
If you were at the press conference, or if you’re reading this and wondering what you can do, use this link to support Right to Counsel in Springfield. You don’t have to live in Springfield to advocate for this, Right to Counsel is a Missouri issue. For our readers in Kansas City and St. Louis: your cities already have RTC programs, and your experience with it is proof of what Springfield is still waiting for. Please use the link to share how a Right to Counsel made a difference for you, your loved ones, or your clients.
